
Guest post by Erik Fessler, a graphic designer and copywriter. Read more of Erik’s work.
Brainstorming is a structured process for generating, developing, and acting on ideas. This guide explains how to create and implement a brainstorming process that separates open-ended idea generation from evaluation so a team can explore widely, combine what works, and leave with a clear next step.
What do you think is worse: sitting for 100 days because you did not know what direction to travel in, or going for 100 days down the wrong path?
That question matters less when you have a reliable way to find the right direction. Brainstorming gives a team a repeatable way to generate ideas, iterate on them, and use its combined creative energy to make a real business change.
The process is more than calling a meeting and asking for suggestions. Good sessions frame the right questions, give people space to think independently, develop ideas together, and convert the strongest option into action.
Alex Osborn was the first person to write about brainstorming in his book Applied Imagination.

Osborn, a Madison Avenue advertising executive, was frustrated by his employees’ difficulty developing creative ideas for campaigns. He began hosting group-thinking sessions in 1939, then formally outlined the practice in his 1953 book on organized creativity.
His method gave creative work a repeatable shape. Instead of waiting for inspiration, participants produced possibilities under a few shared rules. The group could then examine, combine, and improve those possibilities after the generation phase ended. That separation between making options and judging options remains the core of a useful brainstorming session.
The enduring point is not that every problem needs a large group. It is that creativity improves when a team follows clear rules for divergence before it converges on a decision.

Brainstorming can keep a team moving while reducing the chance that it commits too early to the first plausible answer. Using lateral thinking, it asks people to view a problem from a new and unusual angle, then test the result against real constraints.
The basics of a brainstorming process

A brainstorming process relies on two important keys: rapid idea generation and non-threatening communication. The first creates options. The second makes it safe for people to contribute options that are incomplete, unusual, or easy to dismiss too soon.
It is tempting to adopt the first solution you think of while making a tough decision. Unfortunately, the first solution is not always the best. Consider this excerpt from Art & Fear: Observations on the Perils (and Rewards) of Artmaking by David Bayles and Ted Orland:
The ceramics teacher divided the class into two groups. One would be graded only on the quantity of work produced, while the other needed to produce one perfect pot. At the end, the highest-quality work came from the quantity group. They had spent the term making, learning, and improving, while the quality group had spent too much time theorizing about perfection and finished with a pile of dead clay.
The students who did not explore multiple ideas traveled an entire semester down the wrong path. The story explains why effective brainstorming favors volume early: each attempt reveals something that the next attempt can use.
Divergence and convergence should therefore feel different. During divergence, the team searches for range, novelty, and overlooked angles. During convergence, it looks for evidence, constraints, tradeoffs, and combinations. Mixing the two too early turns every suggestion into a miniature debate and reduces the amount of material the team has available to improve.
Ralph Keeney, a decision-analysis scholar at Duke University, has recommended producing several alternatives for every initial solution. The exact ratio matters less than the discipline of looking beyond the first answer.
Rapid idea generation works best in a focused, low-pressure environment. That does not excuse anyone from meeting deadlines. It means criticism and heavy evaluation wait until the group has enough options to compare.
Brainstorming rules
The classic brainstorming rules are simple. Defer criticism while ideas are being generated. Prioritize quantity before quality. Welcome unusual ideas. Combine and improve ideas instead of treating every suggestion as final.
- Separate generation from evaluation so early criticism does not stop the flow.
- Ask for many ideas, because volume gives the group more material to test and combine.
- Make room for unusual suggestions that can reveal a new direction.
- Build on other people’s ideas and record the result so it is not lost.
Every idea should eventually be judged, but that happens after divergence. With the basics in place, the next sections explain how to brainstorm questions, generate ideas alone and together, and turn the result into action.
Step 1: Brainstorm the right questions

The first step to finding better answers is asking better questions. Using brainstorming to expose unknown factors is as important as working together to solve them. The questions you produce guide the group toward useful paths and away from assumptions that have gone untested.
Start by preparing a two-minute pitch that covers the problem or set of problems the group needs to overcome. Respect the time limit. A short framing forces the facilitator to describe the challenge at a high level without quietly steering everyone toward one preferred answer.
Describe how the situation would improve if the problem were solved, but do not color the problem with a proposed solution. Think of yourself as a director giving the actors their motivation, not their lines.
Set two rules before the question burst begins:
- Participants contribute questions, not answers.
- Participants do not add preambles, explanations, or justifications to their questions.
Then set a short timer. Aim for roughly 15 questions in four minutes, but treat that as a pace-setting target, not a score. Encourage challenging questions and do not allow pushback while the questions are being generated.
Record every question in a shared digital note, card stack, or form that the group can review later. Use the fastest surface available. The tool matters less than capturing the exact wording without slowing the room.
A quick check-in can tell the facilitator whether people are confused, guarded, or ready to contribute. Mood is useful context, but it is not a success metric. Do not repeat a session merely until the group reports feeling positive. Instead, look at whether the questions broadened the frame and exposed assumptions the original brief missed.
Once the timer ends, analyze the list. Look for questions that reframe the problem or point toward a new way of solving it. Questions that feel important, surprising, or uncomfortable often deserve a follow-up such as, ‘Why do we not already do this?’ or ‘What constraint are we treating as fixed?’
Sort the questions before answering them. One cluster may expose missing customer evidence, another may reveal an operational constraint, and another may challenge the outcome the team assumed it wanted. Mark which questions require research, which need a decision, and which can be tested quickly. This keeps a provocative question from disappearing just because nobody can answer it in the room.
The next stage forks into two connected methods. Begin with individual brainstorming so each person can think without anchoring on the loudest voice. Then bring those ideas into a group session for combination, challenge, and development.
Step 2a: Individual brainstorming

Individual brainstorming, often called silent ideation or brainwriting, gives each participant time to generate ideas before the discussion starts. Research on group idea generation, including work available through INSEAD and the European Journal of Social Psychology, has long examined the value of combining individual and group work.
The practical benefit is straightforward. People are less likely to anchor on the first suggestion they hear. Quieter team members do not need to fight for airtime. Everyone arrives with material that can be compared rather than waiting for inspiration in front of the room.
Give participants the same problem statement, constraints, and time box. Ask them to write down as many ideas as they can without ranking them. If someone uses AI, use it as a prompt partner or clustering assistant, not as a substitute for the person’s own judgment or the team’s domain knowledge.
When the time is up, collect the ideas before discussion. A facilitator can remove duplicates, preserve unusual options, and make sure every contributor’s work reaches the shared surface. Do not announce the author’s name with each idea unless attribution helps the decision.
Use the same prompt and time box for everyone so the comparison is fair. Ask for rough ideas rather than polished proposals. A sentence, sketch, example, or counterexample may be enough. The goal is to increase the number of distinct starting points before social dynamics begin to narrow the field.
Then move into group review. Each participant should be able to explain the reasoning behind an idea, but the group should evaluate the idea on its fit with the problem and criteria, not on the seniority or confidence of the person who proposed it.
Step 2b: Group brainstorming

Group brainstorming is valuable when a problem benefits from several specialties or perspectives. The purpose is not merely to collect more suggestions. It is to let people combine partial ideas, spot dependencies, and develop an option that no one participant would have produced alone.
Choose participants whose experience is relevant and varied. Different functional backgrounds, career stages, and lived experiences can reveal assumptions that a uniform group may miss. The facilitator’s job is to make participation possible, not to claim that diversity automatically guarantees a better business result.
Prepare a comfortable space and a shared capture surface. If the group is unfamiliar, use a brief warm-up that lets everyone contribute once before the main problem appears. Then define the problem, name the criteria that a viable answer must meet, and include any useful constraints discovered during the question burst.
Ask everyone to share their independent ideas. Give each person a fair chance to contribute and record every idea before debate begins. The facilitator or a dedicated scribe should capture input in a format that remains available after the meeting.
A repeatable system helps the record survive the session. Process Street is one Compliance Operations Platform for governed Docs, repeatable Ops workflows, and built-in AI. A team can capture ideas, route them through criteria and approvals, assign ownership, and keep an auditable decision trail in the same operating process.
Once the ideas are visible, cluster related suggestions. Ask participants to develop someone else’s idea as well as their own. This prevents the session from turning into a sequence of private pitches and makes combination part of the work.
A clear record also makes the session easier to continue asynchronously. Participants can add evidence, note dependencies, and refine a cluster without reopening the entire meeting. A simple process checklist can protect the rules, while a shared decision record keeps the final rationale available to people who were not in the room.
The facilitator should protect one conversation at a time, watch for side debates, and invite people who have not spoken. They should also allow play. Provocations, analogies, and random inputs can break a stale pattern, provided the group returns to the problem and its criteria.
Use breaks strategically during a long session. After each break, restate the problem and ask what new connection the group sees. The goal is not to follow one train of thought forever. It is to explore enough directions to make convergence meaningful.
Step 3: Don’t forget to take action

A strong list of ideas is only an intermediate result. The brainstorming process creates value when the group chooses what to test, assigns responsibility, and records what happens next.
Start by clustering duplicates and closely related ideas. Then evaluate the remaining options against the criteria established in Step 1. Useful criteria might include expected impact, effort, risk, reversibility, customer value, and the time needed to learn whether the idea works.
Choose the strongest option or a small set of contenders. Name an owner, define the next observable action, and set a due point for review. The next action should be concrete enough that another person can tell whether it happened.
Agree on what would change the decision. A cheap test may invalidate an attractive idea, while a small piece of customer evidence may strengthen a less obvious one. Recording the assumption, test, and review date turns disagreement into a learning plan instead of leaving the loudest opinion in control.
Record the decision in a shared process planner or workflow so the idea, evidence, owner, criteria, and follow-up stay connected. A brainstorming note with no owner is an archive. A decision record with a next action is an operating process.
If you are stuck between two promising ideas, consider a small A/B test or another reversible experiment. Define what you expect to learn before the test begins and agree on how the group will interpret the result.
Then review what happened and improve the process. Iteration is key. Theorizing is rarely a replacement for learning through action. Do not let your group’s brainstorming process become a pile of dead clay.